favorite creepypasta! slendy 11 votes Ashley_The_Killer Answer Link jane the killer 2 votes Ashley_The_Killer Answer Link jeff the killer 16 votes Ashley_The_Killer Answer Link ben drowned 19 votes Ashley_The_Killer Answer Link sally 4 votes Ashley_The_Killer Answer Link raven 3 votes Ashley_The_Killer Answer Link hoddie 5 votes Ashley_The_Killer Answer Link masky 8 votes Ashley_The_Killer Answer Link smile dog 3 votes Ashley_The_Killer Answer Link Ashley_The_Killer Ashley published on February 16, 2014 2 polls Follow Create Poll on Qfeast. It's just too easy! Star Poll (1) Comments (11) Lil_Phoenix you forgot Toby- 0 0 reply About Author Report on September 03, 2020 EmptySoul jeff the killer is winning! team jeff! 0 0 reply About Author Report on March 23, 2018 Lucy_Heartfilia *Ben Drowned 0 0 reply About Author Report on June 17, 2016 Lucy_Heartfilia jane. But Ben Drown is winning so far. 0 0 reply About Author Report on June 17, 2016 Puplove88 Smile dog 0 0 reply About Author Report on October 15, 2015 blackposion Masky for the win! 0 0 reply About Author Report on June 17, 2015 MomoCutie I love benny 0 0 reply About Author Report on October 09, 2014 CoughOfFire Raven..?And anyway.. Where's Seedeater?! 0 0 reply About Author Report on August 03, 2014 beeesafe Hoodie is my 2nd. Jackie the cannibal wasn't here! 0 0 reply About Author Report on June 24, 2014 TossedWhisper4 slender, hoodie is second though. :) But for some reason Jeff seems to be a lot of people's fav...not dissing him though, I cherish my life...(and my blood):( 0 0 reply About Author Report on May 05, 2014 gonebitches I'm almost going to bed and I'm going to be scared tonight lol 0 0 reply About Author Report on March 18, 2014 Subscribe
And anyway.. Where's Seedeater?!