paytynn's Favorite Stories paytynn has 21 stories marked as favorite Creepypasta x reader (2) Lost Girl ///( E.J X Reader )/// Grace Maple I Won't I'm in love with a killer~ a jeffxcrystal love story Im in love with a killer Jeffxcrystal love story (continued) Jeff The Killer (love story) Lonely Lonely Jeff The Killer Love Story (part 5) Jeff The Killer Love Story (part 4) Jeff The Killer Love Story (part 3) Jeff The Killer Love Story (part 2) Hers Heartbeat (Ticci Toby x Reader) Jeff the Killer Dear Diary, I think I may have fallen for an EMO Dear Diary, I Love Them Both Insanity Third Wheel 1 2 »